Ebenezer

Oh joy! It’s that time of year again when the movie companies release their Christmas movies, although the middle of November seems far too soon. I’m guessing December is so packed with big movies that there isn’t any room. Anyway, it’s been a few years since we had another Scrooge movie, so we now have Ebenezer, directed by horror director Tim West. While this is as faithful to Charles Dickens’ original story as possible and has signs of the director’s love of the genre, the issue is that we’ve been here before; it feels as if the director has been reigned in, and it has a star who delivers the performance we expected from him, although it’s slightly put to shame by his supporting cast.

Ebenezer Scrooge is a miserable man who works with his partner, Jacob Marley. When Marley dies, he is left alone to become even more miserly with his money and his lack of Christmas joy. The ghost of his former partner appears and tells him three spirits will visit him to show him the errors of his way.

Ti West has gone full Hammer horror, capturing Dickens’ world with its cobbled streets, and you can almost smell the age of the place. He even includes captions that are full Hammer. It has promise from the start, and yet as the film progresses, you can see that this is a man who loves his horror and really goes to town with jump scares and, particularly, the spirits’ grotesqueness. The man who gave us the spooky ghost story The Innkeepers, as well as the X trilogy with Mia Goth, is in his element with the most famous ghost story of all. And yet, it all feels very restrained.

A Christmas Carol has been regarded as the Yuletide story. So all the plot points are here, yet you feel that West wants to go where no other adaptation has gone before, but it feels that Paramount Pictures have told the director to pull in the horror, which seems strange when a story like this is handed to a man who has a strong reputation for delivering shocks.

This isn’t the film’s main tripping point. Where it falls very short of the likes of Alastair Sim’s Scrooge, or even Michael Caine’s performance in Muppet Christmas Carol, which many regard as the greatest version of the story, is in Johnny Depp’s return to the blockbuster world. After being left in the wilderness by the infamous court case, he is back, but his performance as Ebenezer shows just how limited he is as an actor. It’s all show and no substance. It’s made even more obvious by a talented supporting cast who show restraint and subtlety. This is like watching Jack Sparrow if he were aged and no longer a pirate.

There isn’t a moment when he isn’t gurning or overusing his hands, as if he thinks that’s how you show emotion. It would fit perfectly on a stage during a pantomime, but here it looks awkward and out of place, especially when everyone is working so hard to create a genuine atmosphere that gives West chills. That said, West does give Depp a nod to his movie debut by having him swallowed up by his bed, the same way the actor met his fate in A Nightmare on Elm Street.

Rupert grint nicely underplays the bullied assistant Bob Cratchit. The former Harry Potter star knows that overplaying the character will remove any sentiment he requires, and he does exactly that. It’s a nicely controlled performance. Sir Ian McKellen knows how to deliver a theatrical performance, and he does what he does as Marley. The real star is the almost unrecognisable Andrea Riseborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past. With easily the most terrifying make-up job in the whole film, she floats around with an uneasy tone in her voice, and it’s exactly the right balance of creepiness this part deserves.

Given room to do his thing, Ti West could have brought us the most terrifying version of the story, but Ebenezer isn’t the Christmas cheer it should be, and maybe, if he were given a chance to remake it, West could consider casting a different lead. No Christmas cheer here. Humbug!

2 out of 5

Director: Ti West

Starring: Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Ian MacKellen, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Diasy Ridley, Tramell Tillman, Arthur Conti, Ellie Bamber, Henry Lloyd-Hughes, Charlie Murphy, Freddie Lee-Grey

Written by: Nathaniel Halpern and (based on the story A Christmas Carol) Charles Dickens

Running Time: 115 mins

Cert: 12A

Release date: 13th November 2026

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.